EndSARS: FG waiting for panel reports from states

* Controversy, as panel member raises alarm over unfair persecution

* We’re being unfairly persecuted – Ebun Adegboruwa, SAN

* Panel report fraught with errors – Lagos govt counsel, Owonikoko, SAN

* Panel report one of the best ever produced – Falana, SAN; asks FG to sanction Malami, others who tried to cover up Lekki shootings

By Johnbosco Agbakwuru & Olayinka Ajayi

President Muhammadu Buhari said yesterday he will await the steps taken by governors, before the Federal Government would take action on the reports of the judicial panels of enquiry set up by states.

You Might Be Interested In

While those of Rivers, Delta, Ogun, among others, had earlier submitted their reports, the Lagos panel presented its report on police brutality, including the Lekki shooting, to Governor Babajide Sanwo-Olu five days ago.

This came on a day controversies continued to trail report of the panel set up by Lagos State Government as a member of the panel, Mr. Ebun Olu Adegboruwa, yesterday raised an alarm that members of the panel, led by Justice Doris Okuwobi, retd, were being persecuted by agents of the state.

Mr. Abiodun Owonikoko, SAN, counsel to Lagos State Government on the panel, had in an interview on Arise TV yesterday, made comments that tended to raise doubts about the report.

Buhari hosts Blinken

President Buhari, who spoke at a meeting with Antony Blinken, US Secretary of State, in Abuja, yesterday, said state governments will have to take steps on the reports of their

panels, before the Federal Government acts on the recommendations.

He said: “So many state governments are involved, and have given different terms of reference to the probe panels.

“We at the federal have to wait for the steps taken by the states, and we have to allow the system to work. We can’t impose ideas on them. The Federal Government has to wait for the reaction of the states.”

On his part, the US Secretary of State described the report of the #EndSARS probe panel as “democracy in action”, adding that he looked forward to necessary reforms within security agencies.

Speaking on the removal of Nigeria from countries violating religious freedom, Buhari said his administration remained committed to freedom of worship, adding that “no one is discriminated against on the basis of his or her faith”.

He also expressed his appreciation to the US for its support in the sale of military weapons to Nigeria to fight insecurity.

“It’s helping us to stabilise the situation in the North-East, and we’ve made a lot of progress since 2015,” he said.

“We are doing a lot on security, and the people involved appreciate our efforts.”

‘EndSARS panel members being attacked’

Meanwhile, a member of the Lagos panel, Mr. Ebun Adegboruwa, has raised an alarm that members of the panel, led by Justice Doris Okuwobi, retd, were being persecuted by agents of the state.

Mr. Abiodun Owonikoko, SAN, counsel to Lagos State Government on the panel, had in an interview on Arise TV yesterday, made comments that tended to raise doubts about the report.

Another member of the panel, Temitope Majekodunmi, had 24 hours hours earlier, said the report contained errors in spelling of names of some of the victims but also noted that it did not vitiate the content of the report.

But Adegboruwa in a statement yesterday, said: “Since the submission of the EndSARS Panel Report to the Governor of Lagos State on November 15, 2021, members of the panel have become subject of vicious attacks by those suspected to be agents of the government.

“All manner of allegations have been heaped upon panel members, some of who have been called unprintable names.

“I can confirm that no member of the panel lobbied to be appointed into the panel. As a matter of fact, in my own case, His Excellency, the governor of Lagos State, appealed to me to accept my appointment, which I saw as a call to national service.

“The primary reason the governor gave to me then was that he wanted men and women of integrity, independent and not subject to manipulation, to be on the panel.

“Just today (yesterday), my attention has been drawn to an interview by a senior counsel to the Lagos State Government, to the effect that panel members collected bribe in the course of the assignment. It is unfair, ungodly and least expected of the government and its lawyers.

“The Lagos State Government asked for two weeks to enable it release a White Paper on the report submitted to it by the panel. We have been waiting, but it would seem that the Lagos State Government has now unleashed mindless propaganda upon panel members, whilst at the same time asking for restraint from the general public.

“I have in my custody, certified true copies of all proceedings of the panel and all exhibits tendered before the panel in respect of the Lekki Toll Gate investigation. I urge the government to call its agents and lawyers to order so as not to provoke aggravated responses.

“It is unfair to seek to denigrate peoples’ hard-earned reputation on account that they only accepted to render selfless service at the behest of government. If the government and its agents are not restrained from attacking others, nothing stops us from defending our integrity.

“I should not become a victim of unwarranted attack just because I accepted to serve the government and the outcome of that assignment did not favour the expectations of the government.

Suffice to mention that I worked with men and women of unblemished integrity and I’m proud to be associated with them all.

“I, therefore, appeal to His Excellency the Governor of Lagos State to call all agents of state to order and to keep to his promise to us to release a White Paper within two weeks and to send the unedited report of the panel, to the National Economic Council, NEC.’’

Owonikoko had earlier in the interview, said: ‘’I was a retained private solicitor to represent the interest of Lagos State Government at the panel, along with my other colleagues, another SAN, Enitan Olukayode and our colleagues.

“I have avoided having to make comments about proceedings before the panel or their reports up until now, because I know that by law, the panel set up was a judicial panel of inquiry and its decisions, recommendations, resolutions are not meant for public consumption in the first instance.

‘’What they do is to submit a report to the government, which may be a unanimous one or a divided opinion, if the panel members were unable to agree on certain things under their terms of reference. It is government’s own review of that report and its final decision on it that ought to be available for public consumption.

‘’Why is that so? Even the government’s decision on it which comes by way of White Paper is not binding on anybody that is aggrieved and you are entitled to subject it to the judicial review in a court of law.

‘’An instance that you may readily recall was the Oputa Panel. One of the reasons a number of some of the recommendations did not see the light of day, was that it was challenged in court and the Supreme Court held that some of the matters that the panel looked into much as the public was interested in knowing the truth about them, were beyond the remit of the Federal Government to constitute a panel to look into.

‘’Today, I am not speaking for Lagos State Government, I am not speaking on a report that is validly published and which can be authenticated as the outcome of that judicial inquiry. Nevertheless, I can’t pretend not to be aware that certain documents have been circulating in the social media and have been subject of comments and responses.

‘’I have myself seen one of such reports, it is unsigned, but it contains the names of all members and I did not, on going through it, see any indication that it was not a unanimous position.

‘’It may well be, however, that it is a draft of a minority opinion, because giving what I know, having spent one whole year from beginning of the sitting of the panel till the end, except for occasions where one or two of my colleagues had to stand in for me and we have record of proceedings, there was nothing that transpired before the panel that escaped my knowledge.

‘’That been the case, I must say that I am totally shocked about what I read to be the report, particularly the finding, with regards to 40 something victims, some of whom were described as deceased, some of them described as missing but all attributed by the panel to what is called the Lekki incident, that is the undisputed, uncontro-verted fact that the Military personnel got to the Lekki Tollgate around past 06:00PM in the evening as part of mobilization towards enforcing the curfew imposed by Lagos State Government, following the assessment that security situation in the state was at a stage where special attention had to be given security provided to impose a curfew and restore law and order.

‘’As at that morning, Mr. Governor had addressed the state and issued a proclamation for a curfew to commence at 04:00PM. That was presented from what we now knew at the panel by a security council meeting held by the State Government Security Council a day before, involving the Police, the Army, the Navy, the SSS, the Attorney-General, the Governor and a few other government functionaries where they assessed the entire situation and came to the conclusion that things were going out of hand. ‘’As at that time, policemen were being killed, a female orderly to a First Lady was stripped naked and assaulted at Ikorodu.

‘’On the very night this happened, a first-class traditional ruler was lodged at Oriental Hotel and information got to the hoodlums and they were going to attempt his life. It was his own governor who called the Lagos State Governor that my first-class traditional ruler is under threat at Lekki Oriental Hotel.

‘’I am sure you remember that there was an attempt to burn down Oriental Hotel. If that had been allowed to happen, I am sure we would not be talking about Lekki Toll Gate, we would be talking about what led to a first-class traditional ruler visiting Lagos being killed in a hotel.

‘’I don’t want to go into other things. My opinion here is based on my first-hand information and involvement in the proceedings and the record that we have.’’

Owonikoko tackles Adegboruwa

On claims by a member of the panel that though the report contained some typographical errors, it was authentic, Owonikoko said: ‘’Let me first of all say, I wouldn’t know who the panel member that appeared on your channel was.’’.

Told that he was the youth representative on the panel, he said: “I can forgive the youth rep because I will read to you now what the Section 8 of the law that setup the panel says about their report. The Tribunals of Inquiry Law of Lagos State, Section 15.1, “Report and Order in relation to any property or matter dealt with in the report. A Tribunal will make and furnish to the governor, a full report in writing of its proceedings, findings and recommendations and record an opinion and reasons leading to its conclusion.

‘’Any member of the Tribunal dissenting from the conclusions or any part will note his reason for such dissent. This provision has been interpreted as imposing a duty of confidentiality on the panel that conducts an inquiry of this nature, not to disclose the content or discuss its proceedings anywhere except to await the finding of the government on that report.

‘’I am shocked to hear that a member had already come here to start talking about the content. You would then have to go to the oath of office they swore when they started their operation. The oath has to do with fidelity, impartiality, and confidentiality.

‘’If anybody who was a panel member had gone out as at today, while the White Paper is being awaited, to speak to what has happened, that person has breached not only the oath that he took to be a member, he has also breached the duty imposed on them not to discuss or divulge the content to anybody.

‘’What we should be discussing, and is very important, will be the government‘s outcome. That outcome can be criticized, challenged on the back of the original report, but it is what is actionable, justifiable is not whatever is contained in the report.

‘’Let me be clear, I am not in any way trying to shut anybody out, I am just trying to let you know what the law says. And that was why for almost two months now, since the panel closed, I had been invited several times to speak as a protagonist or participant at the panel and I have declined to do so because I know that professionally and legally, it was wrong for me to express opinion or do anything that will appear to prejudice the report.

My grouse with the report, by Owonikoko

‘’So, let’s not waste too much time. I have just explained to you why that would be wrong. A number of them were not lawyers and that to me is actually the crux of the problem we have with this report. And I will tell you the first thing before I come to the other questions.

‘’The questions you have posed about whether it is right to kill, definitely, you know that I can not be part of those who would justify extra-judicial killings or abuse of state power. So, the answer to that is that none of them is acceptable and from the evidence that we were able to gather at the hearing, there was not a single thing that was established, and I would come to that later.

‘’But let me first say this, the panel that was constituted that submitted this report, had two reports. The mistake I observed now that the government made was that there should have been a different panel entirely to look into the Lekki incident.

‘’The panel that was constituted originally was meant to address victims and abuse of police brutality and SARS, there was no single member of the panel who had a personal case that he wanted to establish, there was no reason we should be afraid that anybody there would have a pre-conceived notion or a settled position that they were going to be opened to being persuaded by evidence-led.

‘’Now, in the course of that panel’s work, this incident happened, but this incident had protagonists and antagonists, unfortunately, at least, three members of the panel were picked from those who were protagonists of the case against the police that people like us also represent.

‘’I was fully in support of what was going on up until 20th of October, even up until the night, until I became wiser the next morning when I did my enquiry. Those members are ordinarily not entitled to sit in this panel but they are members of this panel where we were trying to establish who were killed, at Lekki Tollgate, whether Lekki Tollgate Concession Company withdrew camera to suppress information.

‘’This is the case they have been making on their own, even before the panel sat, so from the very beginning, that panel lacks the judicial competence to determine this issue. At the point where the panel, after about four attempts to have the Lekki Tollgate re-opened, they decided to re-open the tollgate.

‘’I am sure you will recall that some members of the panel who were insisting that the Lekki Tollgate must be shutdown because they don’t want that place to be re-opened, they came out on their own and delivered a dissenting opinion asking that Lekki Tollgate should be re-sealed after almost four months and Lekki Concession Company had to submit a claim to its insurers for a loss to the tune of N10bn and they couldn’t do that as it had to be done faithfully without going to the site to identify what they have lost and making an inventory, these members of the panel said they must not open that place.

‘’This shows you something, that some members had a position, and they were not in a position to express dispassionate objective view on the matter that had to do with Lekki. That is the fundamental problem we had.

‘’After that incident, the gentleman, a very respected member for almost the entire duration of the hearing of the Lekki incident stopped coming to the Tribunal, the one that issued that statement and was in the public domain.

HOME
LATEST NEWS
SPORTS
ENTERTAINMENT
VIDEOS
RELATIONSHIPS
POLITICS
FORUM
POSTED INNEWS
EndSARS: FG waiting for panel reports from states — BUHARI
November 19, 2021

*Controversy, as panel member raises alarm over unfair persecution

*We’re being unfairly persecuted – Ebun Adegboruwa, SAN

*Panel report fraught with errors – Lagos govt counsel, Owonikoko, SAN

*Panel report one of the best ever produced – Falana, SAN; asks FG to sanction Malami, others who tried to cover up Lekki shootings